My Favorite Mascaras!
Nolan O'Connor
01-06-2026
· Fashion Team
Lykkers, I firmly believe that a good mascara can completely change a makeup look. Even on days when I'm wearing almost no makeup, a few swipes of mascara instantly make me look more awake and put together.
I've tested quite a few over the years, but these three have been getting the most use lately.

1. Maybelline The Falsies Lash Lift Mascara — 4.8/5

This is the mascara I reach for when I want my lashes to look lifted without having to spend too much time curling them. I love how it adds both length and volume while still keeping my lashes separated. The effect reminds me of a fresh lash lift—defined, lifted, and noticeable without looking too dramatic. It also lasts surprisingly well throughout the day, which is why I keep coming back to it. The only reason it's not a perfect score for me is that I occasionally need to be careful when layering multiple coats.

2. Pinkflash Waterproof Curl Mascara — 4.8/5

Whenever I know I'm going to be out all day, this is usually the mascara I choose. The biggest thing I noticed is how well it holds a curl. Some mascaras start strong but slowly let my lashes droop throughout the day. This one keeps them looking lifted for hours. I also appreciate how lightweight it feels. My lashes stay curled and defined without feeling stiff or crunchy. It's become one of my favorite affordable discoveries and definitely deserves a spot in my makeup bag.

3. Essence Waterproof Volume Mascara — 4.9/5

If volume is what I'm after, this is the mascara I reach for first. It makes my lashes look noticeably fuller with just a few swipes, and I love how it creates that bold, eye-opening effect. Even when I'm keeping the rest of my makeup simple, this mascara makes it look like I put in extra effort. What impressed me most is that it gives dramatic volume without making my lashes look overly heavy. Plus, the waterproof formula holds up really well throughout the day.
These mascaras all earn a spot in my collection for different reasons. The Maybelline The Falsies Lash Lift Mascara is perfect for a lifted, lengthened look. Pinkflash Waterproof Curl Mascara is my choice when I need serious curl retention, and the Essence Waterproof Volume Mascara wins whenever I want fuller-looking lashes. Honestly, I rotate between all three depending on the look I'm going for.